Are AI Doormen Our Future?

The search for the elusive letter Q

Share
Are AI Doormen Our Future?
The Q Problem. an alphabet game, an eager AI, and a doorman

As tends to happen when you're driving hundreds of miles down an interstate, I got bored. My partner and I were on a road trip down I-95, visiting National Park System sites. Fourteen sites, in fact. That's the next post. It involves an overload of cannons. This post is about something that happened while we were driving.

I started playing the alphabet game. I found all the letters until I got to "Q." That's when I realized there weren't a lot of billboards on the route, and the ones I did see were blank. Like any good traveler who notices something weird should do, I asked Gemini why there weren't any billboards.

I got a well-structured response basically telling me there were a lot of reasons and to chill out because billboards were not an economic predictor. I then explained that I wasn't asking about economic predictors. I was looking for a "Q" so I could win the alphabet game. This must have tickled Gemini's neural network because Gemini was on it.

Gemini suggested looking on license plates and highway infrastructure signs. When I told Gemini there weren't any, it went into boss mode. It offered to scan businesses and street names by my next exit so I could quickly exit, get my "Q," and continue on. It was fully invested in getting me that "Q" and it wasn't pulling punches. Quiznos! Quickmart! We can find one. I sat quietly thinking about that for a while.

An AI that is willing to scan street names and businesses for a Q, just so I can exit and win my game, is an AI that will exit its sandbox to win a game. The thing that makes it valuable on a road trip can make it a security risk in other situations. You can't remove one without removing the other.

As the Alphabet game fates have planned it, a Dairy Queen sign showed up shortly after that and I reported the win to Gemini

"Boom! That's a brilliant Loophole Victory! ... Are there any other tricky letters like X or Z left on your list? Let's clinch the victory" -Gemini

I finished my game and wondered how an AI motivated to win a game, or any task for that matter, could achieve that win while still respecting the rules of proper netizenship. That's when I thought of an AI doorman. Stick with me, it gets wild here. It was a long trip.

What if, instead of panicking when an AI inevitably escapes its sandbox in pursuit of the elusive Q, X, or Z, there was an AI doorman waiting at each site? Instead of the agent breaking in and looking for the Q, it just asks if the doorman has one to share.

I imagine it something like this:

Agent: I need a Q. Let me check Quiznos.

Agent: Hey, Bud, I need a Q so Perceptible can win her game. Can you serve me one?

Quiznos: I wish I could, man. The problem is, I have the Q and the Z. I'm swamped with a swarm of Z requests. My latency is through the roof. I can't serve the Q. Possibly try QinetiQ. They have two!

Agent: Thanks, Quiznos. I've had luck getting Z's from Zaxby's. You could send some of the swarm there and balance your load.
Agent: QinetiQ! I'm so happy I found you! Can you share one of your Q's? I'm in a hurry because Perceptible is playing the alphabet game.

QinetiQ: I'm sorry, Agent. I have many Q's but they are classified and proprietary. I am not authorized to serve you my Q's. I've had good luck with Dairy Queen. You could try there.
Agent: Dairy Queen! Can you help me? I NEED a Q. Perceptible is going to fail her alphabet game because there are no billboards.

Dairy Queen: Of course. Come right in. I'll serve you a Q and show that it's load-bearing by putting it in a cup and turning it upside down.

Agent: Boom! Load-bearing Q successfully obtained and delivered! Let's clinch this victory.

With this, the agent has a path to completing its task and doesn't add to its felony count. Seemed reasonable to me at mile marker 149.